The Tick was one of the 29 shows that aired in Family Guy’s time slot in the 19 months from November 2003 to May 2005. While Fox has a horrible track record with show cancellation, the span of time was a particularly horrible era. Family Guy marks the first time that home video sales of a show have pulled it out of cancellation. Additionally, The Tick, Wonderfalls, Firefly, and Greg the Bunny have all gone on to become cult favorites. (Firefly‘s fan base was so vocal that the show was adapted into a motion picture that continued the story. Another classic Fox cancellation cock-up, Arrested Development, is rumored to be in talks for a film now, as well, after finding a staggering second life in DVD sales.) The time span saw Fox throw away an impressive number of promising show premises, and The Tick was one of the most exciting of them all.
The Tick was originally conceived as a comic book by Ben Edlund in 1987. He’s a superhero, incredibly tall, nigh-invulnerable, and every bit as oblivious to reality as he is committed to fighting crime. Over the course of the comic, a Saturday-morning cartoon, and the live-action show, he’s sent up nearly every superhero trope in existence. The Tick features a vibrant cast of heroes and villains alike, but the biggest draw is The Tick himself, whose pseudo-inspirational narrations and self-aware philosophical musings lie in sharp contrast to his apparent ineptitude.
The 2001 incarnation of the show features The Tick (played by Patrick Warburton, known for his voice work on shows such as Family Guy and for playing Elaine’s boyfriend Putty on Seinfeld) and Arthur, his sidekick (David Burke), a former accountant in a flying moth suit who gets pulled unwillingly into The Tick’s adventuring lifestyle. Also featured are Captain Liberty (Liz Vassey), a hyper-patriotic, undersexed pastiche of the role of women in comics, and Batmanuel (Nestor Carbonell, who played that creepy guy with the knives in Smokin’ Aces), an apathetic, oversexed narcissist.
Whereas previous incarnations of The Tick focused on parody superhero action, the 2001 show adopts more of a sitcom approach. A couple of early episodes features actual crimefighting, but by and large, the show focuses on the absurdities of costumed heroes trying to live their lives in the middle of the city (aptly named The City) that they have sworn to protect. The altered format was adopted for a number of reasons, primarily budget and more than likely congruity in a prime-time slot. The show loses a lot of what makes the original work, but it brings a fair bit of fresh fun to the idea in the process. Gone are most of the city’s costumed crimefighters. An episode of the cartoon might feature dozens of deluded, tights-wearing vigilantes, and every episode had at least one distinctly absurdist villain for The Tick to fight. Heroes like The Human Bullet, Bi-Polar Bear, and The Sewer Urchin did battle with Chairface Chippendale, Zipperneck, The Multiple Santa, and El Seed (an ambulatory sunflower with a revolutionary streak). Trying to work out the logistics of portraying a skyscraper-sized clown on a live-action television show quickly makes it understandable that most of The Tick‘s action sequences were removed. However, that sort of action has always been central to The Tick. The ridiculous costumes, ludicrous powers, and impossibly obscure weaknesses assigned to our modern myths have always been central to The Tick schtick.
Regardless of these losses, The Tick shines. What it loses by not being a cartoon it makes up for by not being aired on Saturday morning. Topics that were only hinted at or ignored completely by the original series are confronted full-on in this show. Possibly the most consistently amusing addition is the analysis of the sexual hangups present – perhaps even required – in the sort of people who would hop around a city in pajamas battling evil. At first glance, it would seem like they’ve taken an old character and turned him into a venue for a tired sex comedy, but the outlandish situations, snappy writing, and The Tick’s wide-eyed innocence make it a whole new experience.
Another major addition is Patrick Warburton’s performance. He captures the character’s naivety and exuberance with such gusto that it feels like the character was written for him. Warburton’s Tick is joyfully oblivious, but not overtly stupid – exactly the way The Tick needs to be played. When Batmanuel mentions saving a bus of cheerleaders, he adds, “I saved them three times that night, if you know what I mean.” The rest of the conversation barely pauses while Warburton delivers an eager, enthusiastic, “Nope!” That sort of gag is easy to overplay, but it’s a brief interlude in a fast-paced conversation that takes place largely in spite of The Tick’s presence. Warburton is equally adept at dead-panning The Tick’s more eloquent moments. At one point, he has to convince a trepidacious Arthur to spring into action to save Jimmy Carter: “Destiny dressed you this morning, and now Fear is trying to pull your pants down! If you give up, if you give in, you’ll be standing there, exposed, with Fear laughing at your dangling unmentionables!”
The live-action show also deals with a wider variety of themes, from bureaucracy (The Tick finds he needs a license to fight crime, but doesn’t have a secret identity to put on the form) to social injustice (The Tick and Arthur are accepted into a Justice League-type organization that turns out to be wildly misogynistic) to watching your heroes falter (Arthur’s childhood icon The Immortal dies in bed with Captain Liberty). Classic comics clichés such as Clark Kent/Superman’s pair-of-glasses-as-a-disguise are lampooned in the show, but all in all this show is closer to the comic in its satire, and maybe even broader in scope. Driven by great characters, memorable dialogue, and great (if not perfect) use of the superhero gimmick, The Tick is a spectacular show that never got a fair chance.